Home Depot or Wayfair — where should a furniture supplier focus?
Sell on both, but start with one. Start with Wayfair if your strength is assortment, room-scene content and fast drop-ship from a US warehouse: Wayfair’s model is built around drop-ship, it sets the retail price from your base cost, and it pays the shipping to the customer. Start with Home Depot if your strength is clean item data and compliance: it is a merchant-led vendor account where every item passes Home Depot’s review before it gets a SKU. Get the first account running clean, then add the second.
How the two retailers differ, point by point
Both are supplier relationships, not open marketplaces: you sell to the retailer at a cost, and the retailer sets the price the shopper sees. The differences are in how you get in, who ships, what the item data has to look like, and how you get paid.
- 1
Getting in
Home Depot starts with a pitch. Merchandise suppliers submit through Home Depot’s New Product Submission site, and Home Depot’s page says its merchant team will contact you within 60 days; a merchant has to want the line. Wayfair starts with an application: the Apply to Sell form on Wayfair’s supplier site, with your business details such as your business registration number on hand. In our experience Wayfair is the faster door for a new brand with a broad catalog; Home Depot is the better door for a tight assortment a merchant can picture in a category.
- 2
Who sets the price
Both retailers do. On Wayfair you set a base cost — Wayfair’s page calls it the starting price at which you sell your products to Wayfair — and Wayfair sets the retail. On Home Depot you quote the online cost to the merchant, and Home Depot’s IDM deck says the online merchant reviews and decides the retail later. Your margin is set at the cost line on both; the difference is who you negotiate it with.
- 3
Who ships, and who pays the freight
Wayfair’s page says drop-shipping is its primary method of fulfillment: the order comes to your warehouse, you pick and pack, and orders ship on Wayfair’s own parcel, LTL and white-glove shipping accounts, so Wayfair covers the cost of shipping to the customer while you arrange the pickups. Suppliers who cannot drop-ship can send stock into CastleGate, Wayfair’s own warehouse network. Home Depot’s deck describes two online routes: ship to a Home Depot distribution center, which then ships to the customer, or ship direct to the customer, which Home Depot says requires a warehouse in the US. The freight term, collect or prepaid, comes from your supplier agreement. In practice that means Wayfair is lighter on freight cost and heavier on fulfillment speed; Home Depot gives you more choice and more rules.
- 4
Item setup and review
Home Depot is the stricter of the two at setup. Every item goes into IDM to the category data standard — the product name formula, bullets, marketing copy, images and documents — then through Home Depot’s internal review, and an item that fails comes back in Error with no SKU until it passes. Wayfair’s setup runs through Partner Home: one product page per item, with room-scene images and complete dimensions and weights, and suppression rather than a review loop when something is missing. Either way the catalog that wins is the one prepared to the standard before it is entered. Field by field for Home Depot: the product content checklist.
- 5
How you are measured
Wayfair’s page points suppliers to fill rate, cancellations, returns and order incidents in the Operations Hub in Partner Home, and in our experience those numbers decide how much of your catalog Wayfair shows. Home Depot measures compliance: the ship notices, labels, routing and item data its supplier programs require, with chargebacks for misses, and a vendor scorecard that affects how much of your line the merchant promotes. Wayfair punishes slow; Home Depot punishes wrong.
- 6
Getting paid
Wayfair pays on its standard terms through Partner Home, with a faster option for a fee, and each payment statement nets out deductions — returns, shipping chargebacks, damage claims. Home Depot pays on the terms in your supplier agreement, with a remittance advice that lists every deduction by code and a dispute queue for each kind. Both need reconciling every time; on both, the deductions nobody reviews are the ones that cost the most. For Home Depot: how to reduce chargebacks and deductions.
- 7
Which one first
Pick the retailer your operation already fits. If you have a US warehouse that can ship a parcel or an LTL order the day it arrives, deep assortment and good lifestyle photography, Wayfair will reward it immediately. If your item data is clean, you can meet document and routing rules without drama, and a merchant has shown interest in a specific line, Home Depot will. Get that account live and stable — every item showing, inventory accepted daily, deductions reconciled — and then add the other with the same item master.
Running both without doubling the work
The item data is the same product described two ways. Build one item master — dimensions and weights at every packaging level, materials, assembly and care details, images on white and in the room, documents — and feed both retailers from it, so a correction is made once. Send inventory to both from the same warehouse count, every day, and tie sets and kits to their components on both so a set stops selling when a part runs out.
Then check every item’s status on both every day. The failure modes differ — an item in Error on Home Depot, a suppressed item on Wayfair — but the loss is the same: an item that is not showing has a sales rate of zero. That daily check across both catalogs is the single habit we would keep if we could keep only one.
After these two
Home Depot and Wayfair are where we tell most home furnishing suppliers to start, and they are the two retailers our own platform has custom-built pages for. Once both are clean, the same item master opens Overstock / Bed Bath & Beyond, Amazon Vendor Central and Direct Import, Walmart, Target, Lowe’s and Costco, each with its own guide on this site.
What we have seen across both
Williams Imports built their online business on Wayfair first — it was their largest channel in their first two years with us — and went from about $10,000 a month to over $4 million a year within two years, best month $586,000. Other suppliers we manage started on Home Depot because a merchant wanted a specific line, and added Wayfair once the drop-ship operation was proven. Neither order is wrong. The suppliers who struggle are the ones who open both at once with a half-finished item master and no one checking status daily.
We manage both retailers inside the supplier’s own accounts, on one monthly plan, month to month with no long-term contract, and the same team runs the item master, the inventory feed and the daily status check for both. Grow eCommerce has done this for home furnishing suppliers for more than 10 years.
Frequently asked questions
Can I sell the same products on Home Depot and Wayfair?
Yes, and most of the suppliers we manage do. Both retailers set their own retail price from the cost you give them, so give both a cost that leaves a workable retail. In our experience merchants on both sides notice when the same item is priced very differently, so keep your costs consistent and let each retailer price from there.
Do I need a US warehouse for both?
For Wayfair, its page says you need a warehouse or third-party logistics partner in North America to deliver orders, or you ship stock into CastleGate. For Home Depot, the IDM deck says shipping direct to the customer requires a warehouse in the US, while the alternative is shipping to a Home Depot distribution center. If you do not have one, see our 3PL program and how we work with factories.
Is Wayfair a marketplace like Amazon?
No. Wayfair buys from you at your base cost and sets the retail price; the customer is Wayfair’s. That is the same structure as a Home Depot vendor account, which is why the item master, the inventory feed and the daily status check carry over between the two.
Which is easier to get approved on?
Wayfair’s route is an application form; Home Depot’s is a product pitch that a merchant has to accept, and Home Depot says its merchant team replies within 60 days. In our experience a new brand with a broad catalog gets live on Wayfair sooner; a supplier with a tight assortment a merchant wants can move quickly on Home Depot. The full route for Home Depot: how to become a Home Depot online supplier.
Which is harder to run day to day?
They are hard in different places. Home Depot has more rules — item review, compliance programs, routing, document timing — and charges back when they are missed. Wayfair has fewer rules and faster expectations: ship on time, keep the feed accepted, keep the listing complete, or the item slides. Both need someone in the portal every day.
Can Grow eCommerce manage both for us?
Yes. We run Home Depot and Wayfair for home furnishing suppliers inside your own vendor accounts — item setup, content, images, inventory feeds, orders, compliance, deductions and the daily status check — on one plan. Start with the free retailer scorecard, which shows what is and is not live on each.
See what is live on each retailer before you decide
Our free retailer report checks your catalog on Home Depot, Wayfair and the other retailers you sell through, item by item, and shows what is not live or sellable and why.
Sources
- Wayfair — Beginner’s guide for suppliers: drop-shipping as the primary fulfillment method; CastleGate Fulfillment Services; base cost and Wayfair setting the retail price; orders billed to Wayfair’s parcel, LTL and white-glove shipping accounts with the supplier arranging pickups; Partner Home; Operations Hub (fill rate, cancellations, returns, order incidents); warehouse or 3PL in North America; Apply to Sell; a faster-payment option for a fee
- The Home Depot — Becoming a Supplier (prospective supplier help center): New Product Submission; merchant team contact within 60 days
- The Home Depot — Onboarding New Items in IDM (April 2021, PDF): category data standard; internal review and items in Error; online cost quoted to the merchant and retail decided by the online merchant; ship to a Home Depot distribution center vs direct to the customer (US warehouse required); freight term collect or prepaid per the Supplier Buyer Agreement
- The Home Depot Supplier Hub
Retailer rules change often; we re-check these pages on every review.